Johann Buttstett
Johann Heinrich Buttstett was a German Baroque organist and composer, born on 25 April 1666 in Binderleben, now a district of Erfurt. He came from a well-educated family; his father, Johann Henricus Buttstett, was a local pastor who had studied at the University of Erfurt. Buttstett began studying music in his youth, and from 1678 he trained under Johann Pachelbel, who at that time served as organist at the Predigerkirche in Erfurt. This early education placed Buttstett in direct contact with one of the most important figures of the South German organ tradition, in which he would later be recognized as one of the last significant exponents. His surname also appears in variant spellings such as Buttstedt and Buttstädt.
By 1684 Buttstett secured his first professional position as organist at the Reglerkirche, and three years later he moved to the Kaufmannskirche. Alongside his organ duties, he taught in church schools, counting among his pupils Johann Gottfried Walther and Georg Friedrich Kauffmann, who would themselves become significant composers. On 19 July 1691 he succeeded Nicolaus Vetter as organist of the Predigerkirche, the post previously held by Pachelbel. Buttstett served in this position for thirty-six years until his death on 1 December 1727 at the age of sixty-one, establishing himself as a central figure in the musical life of Erfurt and gaining recognition for surrounding himself with an active circle of students.
Buttstett became most widely known for his intellectual dispute with Johann Mattheson, a debate that reflected conflicting views on the future of music education. In 1716 he published his treatise "Ut, mi, sol, re, fa, la, tota musica et harmonia aeterna," written as a rebuttal to Mattheson’s earlier work, which promoted more modern approaches aligned with emerging classical tendencies and emphasized French and Italian secular styles. Buttstett defended older musical traditions, advocating practices such as solmization and composition in ancient Greek modes, and upholding long-established conceptions of harmony. He also opposed Mattheson’s work "Das neueröffnete Orchestre," composed in the galant style. Mattheson responded in 1717 with "Das beschützte Orchestra," and Buttstett replied again in 1718 with his "Offentliche Erklärung," though this last publication received little attention.
In his personal life, Buttstett married Martha Lemmerhirt in 1687, a distant relative of Johann Sebastian Bach’s mother. The couple had ten children. Two of their sons, Johann Laurentius and Johann Samuel, followed their father’s path and became organists, continuing the family’s musical legacy.
Buttstett’s surviving works consist exclusively of keyboard music. His only extant collection, "Musicalische Clavier-Kunst und Vorraths-Kammer" (1713), contains a variety of pieces such as fughettas, fantasies, fugues, ricercars, capriccios, and preludes. In this volume he claimed authorship of over one thousand works, although only the collection itself, two marches included in "Ut, mi, sol…," and several dozen chorale preludes are known today. The collection also includes several dance suites that show clear French influence, distinguishing them from the more typical German suites of the period. His operas, cantatas, and masses have been lost.
The influence of his teacher Pachelbel is evident in much of Buttstett’s music, yet many stylistic features indicate familiarity with the North German organ school. His free preludes and fantasies, as well as his stricter fugues and ricercars, show characteristics associated with composers like Dieterich Buxtehude and Nicolaus Bruhns. His works often feature extended virtuosic passages, markedly different from Pachelbel’s reserved writing. An example is his Prelude and Capriccio in D minor, whose prelude opens with rapid single-line passages interrupted by rests, while the capriccio takes the form of a fugue built on a demanding subject written in thirty-second and sixteenth notes.
One of Buttstett’s fugues was discovered in a manuscript belonging to Andreas Bach, further demonstrating his engagement with complex contrapuntal writing. The fugue’s subject displays an extreme use of repercussion technique, including a leap of a diminished seventh, and this repercussive writing appears throughout the piece, at times applied to full chords in both hands. Buttstett’s surviving music and theoretical writings together reveal a composer deeply committed to the preservation of older musical traditions, even as the musical culture of his time moved steadily toward new stylistic ideals.
Connections
This figure has 2 connections in the art history graph.